5 Amazing Tampa Bakeries For Delicious Thanksgiving Pie
What’s your favorite pie for Thanksgiving? Is it the ultimate showdown between Apple and Pumpkin in your house? Do you have a chocolate pie lover or a weird uncle who only eats Mince pie? No matter your favorite, these Tampa bakeries offer the best pies for Thanksgiving.
After the back-to-back hurricanes this year, it’s now more important than ever to support the local businesses that worked their butts off to keep the community fed, and back up and running after a devastating hurricane season.
There have been a few Reddit threads inquiring about where to order pies for Thanksgiving this year. We listed some of the best options and added a few of our own favorites.
5 Tampa Bakeries With Delicious Thanksgiving Pies
Who has time to bake a pie from scratch for Thanksgiving? Not many people do. Skip the frozen, store bought pie this year too, it’s never as good as the real thing. If you’re looking for a good-quality homemade pie for your table this year, consider ordering from a local Tampa Bakery. We’ve got a list of some great options below.
1. Mike’s Pies
Obviously the first on our list has to be Mike’s Pies. Their prices are totally reasonable and they are known to have some of the best pies in the area. They even battled (and won) on Good Morning America a couple years ago in 2022. Their winning pie on Good Morning America featured a gluten-free graham cracker crust, authentic Nellie and Joe’s Key Lime juice. Mike’s Pies is located at 10350 Windhorst Road Suite 100 Tampa. Check out their menu here.
2. Elevenses
This Lord of the Rings inspired bakery is serving up some delicious pies for pick up. They range from $45-50 in price and include options like Macnut pie (caramel filling with macadamia nuts, and Valrhona chocolate), Key lime and passionfruit pie, brownie pie, pumpkin sugar cookie pie, and even a mini Gilmore Girls holiday menu. Click HERE to place your order! Or check them out in person at 1001 E Columbus Dr, Tampa.
3. Sucré Table
Sucré Table is owned by local baker Brenda Villacorta. You may have seen her on season 4 of Halloween Baking Championship, and on Cake Wars Christmas. Their pies weigh between 3 to 3.5 pounds are made with the finest seasonal ingredients and baked to perfection. I ordered her caramel apple pie for my family last year and it was a HUGE hit! These pies are little more expensive, but totally worth it. You can choose to preorder a whole pie in the following flavors: Caramel Apple, Silky Pumpkin, Boozy Bourbon Pecan, Calamansi Merengue Tart, or Frangelico Blackberry Tart. Click HERE for more info or head to 4048 W Kennedy Blvd, Tampa.
4. Chocolate Pi
We saw this Seminole Heights bakery mentioned a few times on the Reddit thread. And after a quick peek at their Instagram, we see why! They have so many flavors to choose from and a whole pie is only $40, or you can get 3 for $100. Some of the flavors they have this year are: Old-fashioned apple pi, Southern Pecan pi, German Chocolate Cake Pi, Bourbon Butterscotch pi, Lemon Meringue pi, Pumpkin Pi, S’mores pi, and more! Check them out at 5207 N. Florida Avenue, Tampa. Or order online here.
5. Moreno Bakery
We’ve heard from Reddit that Moreno Bakery in Brandon is totally worth the drive for their Cuban coffee, cookies, brownies, cakes, guava turnovers, and even Cuban sandwiches. Their Thanksgiving pies are a steal for only $16! You can find them at 737 W. Brandon Blvd., Brandon, FL or order online here.
